After ten years of HUB History, we are winding down production this fall. To celebrate a decade of this podcast, we held a live podcast recording and series wrap party at Old North Church on Friday, November 13, 2026. Lori Rogers-Stokes and Jonathan Chu joined Jake onstage to discuss Puritans, Pope’s Night, and Boston’s spiritual evolution over nearly 400 years. Listeners will never know that everyone in the room suffered through a hissing boiler, a coughing fit that rendered me speechless, and a blaring fire alarm that brought the fire department to Old North to check on the snacks we were attempting to warm up for the wrap party. Enjoy this penultimate episode, and get any listener feedback you’d like to share in soon! I’ll release one more episode in December or January to share all the emails and DMs people have sent in over the past few months.
Pope’s Night LIVE at Old North Church
- Jake Sconyers has been the host of the HUB History podcast for the past decade. Before that, he was a Boston tour guide, a volunteer docent at Roxbury’s Shirley-Eustis House, and an organizer of History Camp Boston. He is also the producer of Queer Boston’s Pursuit of Happiness, a new podcast from Queer History Boston.
- Lori Rogers-Stokes is a public historian and a scholar of the Puritan and later Congregational churches in New England. Her book Heroic Souls explored the powerful and confident religious identities revealed in conversion narratives by 17th century Puritan women, while the more recent Gathered into a Church describes how the indigenous nations of Puritan New England observed and sometimes embraced the Congregational church that was thrust into their midst.
- Jonathan M. Chu is Professor of History Emeritus at the University of Massachusetts Boston and the Bernard Bailyn Emeritus Editor of The New England Quarterly. The author of Neighbors, Friends, and Madmen: The Puritan Adjustment to Quakerism in Seventeenth-Century Massachusetts and Stumbling Toward the Constitution: The Legal and Economic Impact of the American Revolution, he has also written on subjects ranging from the Chinese Exclusion Act to the assessment of teaching history. He has been a member of the Board of
Trustees of the College Board, the Council of the Colonial Society of Massachusetts, and the vice-chair of the Board of Old North Illuminated, the secular fund-raising non-profit that supports Old North Church.
Thanks to Dan Fox of Wondersmith Audio for engineering our live recording session.
Chapters
| 0:07 | Hub History’s Bittersweet Finale |
| 2:54 | Old North Church and Its Layered History |
| 6:13 | Pope’s Night: Boston’s Rowdy Tradition |
| 17:11 | Meet the Historians: Puritan Beliefs |
| 24:15 | Religious Dissent in Early Massachusetts |
| 29:35 | Andros, Christmas, and Colonial Power |
| 36:21 | Pope’s Night as Protest and Political Theater |
| 39:26 | Church Divisions and Congregational Disputes |
| 42:19 | Who Paid the Ministers? |
| 49:44 | Massachusetts Disestablishes Its Churches |
| 53:20 | Puritan Laws and Blasphemy |
| 55:46 | What Comes After Hub History? |
Transcript
Jake:
All right, for the last time.
Hub History’s Bittersweet Finale
Jake:
Welcome to Hub History, where we go far beyond the freedom trail to share our favorite stories from the history of Boston, the hub of the universe. This is episode 366, live at Old North Church. Hi, I’m Jake. I’m seeing all the faces that I mostly just imagined from the far side of a laptop screen, which is very cool. Listeners at home might notice that this episode is slightly different than usual. We are, in fact, recording live at Old North Church in Boston tonight in front of a live audience for the very first time. It’s our first live episode of Hub History. It’s also our final episode of Hub History. So this is a very bittersweet moment for me. This has been very much a labor of love for a decade now.
Jake:
For this last episode, in just a few minutes, I’m going to welcome Lori Rogers Stokes and Jonathan Chu to share the stage with me, and we’re going to talk about some history. I thought it’d be fun to bookend the last episode of the podcast building off of the first. So our very first episode in November of 2016 focused on Pope’s Night in Boston, which was a very bizarre holiday, very anti-Catholic holiday. We’ll get into it momentarily, but we’re going to use that as a bridge to talk about how the influences of the Puritan founders of Boston still resonate in Boston today. And then I also want to reflect on what that means for how the attitudes in Boston and in New England have changed over these almost four centuries since our founding. At the time of the founding and right up through the turn of the 19th century, Massachusetts was considered the most conservative British colony.
Jake:
And then today we have this reputation as the most progressive or one of the most progressive American states. So we’re going to look a little bit at how that change happens. Hopefully we’ll get there through the lens of retelling Pope’s Night one more time. So before I introduce our panelists and bring Lori and Jonathan up here, there are a few things to start with, including some acknowledgements. And the first acknowledgement has to go to Old North Illuminated for hosting us here this evening. This podcast wrap party would not be possible without their hospitality welcoming us today. And to tell you more about Old North Illuminated, their mission, and what they do to steward the Old North Church, we have invited Nikki Stewart to join us on stage. Nikki is the executive director of Old North Illuminated. Long-time listeners will also know her as co-host Emerita Nikki, who started this show with me in 2016 and then wrote about half the episodes for the first four or five years of the show, co-hosted with me for years, and then… Got this wonderful opportunity at Old North Illuminated.
Old North Church and Its Layered History
Nikki:
Welcome everyone to Old North. I’m so excited to have all of you here tonight and to host the final Hub History taping. Old North Illuminated is the nonprofit organization that manages tourism, preservation, and education here at Old North. We are a secular organization, but we work very closely with the congregation of Old North. There is still an active church community here today as well. And, you know, we like to say that Old North Church is not just a one-night stand in history. Of course, it does tell the story of patriots who risked everything to defend their liberty, to fight back against tyranny, to protect their community, lessons that we all still need to carry forward today. But in an overarching span, I think that Old North’s history, and really the North End’s history, is a microcosm of our nation’s history. Old North is, to many people, an icon of liberty, and yet it is funded in part by the proceeds of enslavement. It is founded in the construct of colonialism. It is a community where, for a very long time, People were united in their faith, but divided by their race and their class.
Nikki:
And it is set in a 300-year-old community where generations of immigrants have come to pursue the American dream. And so I think this is a good way for all of us to end our 250 year with this particular topic here tonight in this particular place. And I think, you know what, I think I’ll leave it at that. I have no more to say.
Jake:
Well, thank you for joining us on the show one last time, Nikki, This is the part of the show where usually I would thank our most recent podcast sponsors. I would probably beg and plead with more people to become sponsors. But because we’re all here together in the same room at the beautiful Old North Church, I want to do things a little bit differently and just acknowledge a few of our sponsors who I think are in the room tonight. So if I call your name, give a little wave or raise your hand or something so we know you’re here. Derek Lessing, I know I saw. Give a little thank you. Faithwise, are you here? Very cool. Very nice to meet you. Josh Lankford, Mariana McCormick, I saw. Hello. Richard Lavoie. Nice to meet you as well. Robert Knapp or Knapp. Nice. And Tom Norris. Is there anybody here who I didn’t acknowledge? I did a really quick comparison between our registration list and the sponsor list. Anybody who’s thrown a few dollars in on PayPal or gives on Patreon, I forgot to mention, feel free to throw your hand up as well so I can say thanks. Thank you.
Jake:
Literally, we couldn’t do this without you, both by supporting the show for these many years. I know some of the folks who I just acknowledged have been supporting the show since we first opened a Patreon, but also your money helped buy the refreshments and things tonight. So we literally couldn’t have had tonight without you. So thank you very much. And thanks to everybody who’s come out to make tonight a party. I really appreciate it. There were a lot of last minute registration. So I really appreciate everybody who’s here in the room tonight for our final show.
Pope’s Night: Boston’s Rowdy Tradition
Jake:
Okay. So before I turn things over to Jonathan and Lori, I’m going to spend just a few minutes reintroducing the topics of Pope’s Night to everybody. This takes us back to the very first episode of Hub History, which came out right in time for the anniversary of Pope’s Night in 2016. Pope’s Night is what in colonial Boston, people called the holiday that’s known in other parts of the British Empire is Guy Fawkes Day. In episode one, I think it was about eight or 10 minutes of narration about this. Back then, our research was pretty cursory. We’d skim a Wikipedia or two, and I wasn’t a great writer yet. I hadn’t learned to slow down and speak clearly into the mic yet. Although if you’re listening tonight, you might think that I still haven’t. So my goal tonight is to try to recap Pope’s Night in a way that makes a little bit of sense, but also doesn’t take too long. So I’m going to try to race episode one and do it in about 10 minutes or less. I will say, if you want a more complete introduction to Pope’s Night, way back in episode 75, which came out about 18 months into the show, we have a little bit more of a complete recapping. You can always go back and listen to that. So way back in 1603.
Jake:
King James I came to the throne in England, and there were still some rump Catholics in England who thought that would be a great moment to try to reestablish a Catholic crown in England. Of course, Henry VIII had taken Britain out of the Catholic Church, officially made it its own Church of England.
Jake:
In late October of 1605, just a couple of years after James I ascended, a member of the House of Lords got a cryptic letter warning him to avoid Parliament during a joint address to Parliament on November the 5th, remember the 5th of November, of 1605. He became suspicious he passed that along to some of the chief ministers and, sure enough on the night of or on the day of November the 5th a man named Guy Fawkes is found in a sub-basement underneath the parliament building, standing near a very strange looking pile of firewood underneath the firewood there are barrels of gunpowder they find matches and fuses and all kinds of suspicious items on Guy Fawkes because he’s been planning to blow up parliament, and James I, and hopefully establish the young Princess Elizabeth as a new Catholic monarch. Of course, this doesn’t play very well. Once this is discovered, Guy Fawkes is sentenced to be hanged, drawn, and quartered, manages to avoid that fate by conveniently tripping and falling from the gallows and breaking his neck, which falling and breaking your neck and dying is usually not the best way for a day to end, but if it was otherwise, going to end with being drawn and quartered, I suppose it’s a better option.
Jake:
From there, Guy Fawkes Day becomes pretty quickly celebrated in England by the Protestant masses as sort of a patriotic victory of our Protestant crown over these scheming Catholic usurpers. By the 1620s-ish, it’s being celebrated in England with bonfires, processions, illuminations, sort of lighted lanterns hung up for decorations. It crosses the pond by the mid-1620s in a small way. The first time I could find a record of Guy Fawkes Day being celebrated in New England was around 1623 in Plymouth. The celebration was mostly carried out by sailors, it seems like, so maybe it wasn’t all townsfolk participating. Really takes off in Boston after the 1680s. And once the panel joins me up here, we’ll talk a.
Jake:
Pope’s Nights being celebrated in a big way in Boston. So again, they take those simple bonfires that have been the traditional way of celebrating Guy Fawkes Day in England. And sure, they have bonfires. They have processions. Processions get bigger and rowdier over the years. Different groups. So there’s a North End gang and a South End gang. And when you think of the South End gang, don’t think of today’s South End. Think more like the Financial District or Downtown Crossing is the South End and the the early 18th century. These two gangs would each build these huge 20, 30, 40 foot long floats, sometimes multiple stories of floats, these huge wagons with sort of animated figures of the Pope, the devil, unpopular politicians in whatever year. They’d parade those through the streets with the North End group wanting to wind up their procession at Copts Hill where they’d burn the Pope in effigy. The South End Group was trying to do the same thing at Boston Common. And most of the time they’d meet around today’s Blackstone Block, around the Mill Dam, and have a good old-fashioned street fight and try to steal each other’s floats, steal each other’s effigies of the Pope. And bloodshed would often ensue from that.
Jake:
You can sort of glean from the type of celebration who some of the celebrants were. This tended to be a very working-class celebration, apprentices, free servants, enslaved African-Americans, sailors, laborers. It wasn’t really an upper-class celebration. So the upper classes aren’t really participating willingly in Guy Fawkes Day or Pope’s Night in Boston, but they do get dragged into it against their will often because these mobs, will go door-to-door and essentially blackmail people into turning over cash, alcohol, other goodies. Because they don’t want to get their windows broken, their houses torn down, any sort of mischief carried out against them. So they’re kind of forced to support the Guy Fawkes celebrations, whether they want to or not.
Jake:
I’ve been drawing a lot of parallels between Pope’s Night and the way Christmas was celebrated around the same time in England with mummery being another form of sort of lower class misrule where, all the social structures were upended for one night to celebrate Christmas. You also sort of go around and demand treats from upper class households. So it’s interesting how that’s carried over in early colonial Boston, though in a different time of year.
Jake:
Because this is so violent injuries and fatalities are super common you have people getting crushed by wagons people drowning in the mill creek, you have all kinds of injuries often fatalities you have a couple of notable, participants uh henry knox our first secretary of war famous bookseller turned patriot who brings the cannons back from fort ticonderoga, made his name as a teenager as like the most brutal street fighter in the South End gang on Guy Fawkes Night. Isaiah Thomas, who goes on to be the publisher of the Massachusetts Spy, one of the most prominent Patriot printers, writes in his memoir in 1810 about almost dying from a brick to the head on Pope’s Night back in the 1750s or 60s. And he says, it did not speak very well for the refinement of manners in what was then the most cultivated town of British America. It’s worth perhaps the passing notice of those who are continually asking why the former days were better than these. I love this quote because it’s reflective of, you know, maybe the good old days weren’t so good after all. So he says, good old days, sure, until you take a brick to the face and almost die. There were all kinds of attempts to suppress Pope’s night through the 1740s, 50s, 60s. Some specific town statutes are passed. Also, the Riot Act is read at several Pope’s nights. There’s a law passed saying essentially any three people wearing masks or carrying weapons such as clubs could be subject to fine, imprisonment, or even whipping.
Jake:
None of this works. People love Pope’s Night. They’re not giving it up, despite the fact that it’s illegal, until the culture starts to change in the 1760s and 70s, because we start to have some different shared enemies. After the Seven Years’ War, one of the first shifts is that now these hated French Catholics, instead of being a neighboring empire, are fellow Brits now. They’re right up there in Canada. The other thing that starts to happen is we can be more unified against an outside foe. So during the Stamp Act protests of 1765, there’s a real effort to turn the energy of Pope’s Night toward Stamp Act protests instead. John Hancock starts to fund parties, essentially, to bring, instead of having a street fight, you can come to a party and we’ll give you alcohol. You don’t have to come and threaten to break our windows to get the alcohol. You can just come to the party and have a union feast where we march against British taxation instead of burning the Pope on Copse Hill. And then really the nail in the coffin for Pope’s night becomes the American Revolution for a couple of reasons. First of all, because during the siege of Boston, all the patriotic young Bostonians who might’ve been tempted to celebrate Pope’s night have mostly left Boston and joined the Patriot lines or at least vacated so they can make a living outside of besieged Boston. And then also we Americans are trying to curry the favor of the French-Canadian Catholics up in Canada at this point. We wanted them to join the revolution on our side.
Jake:
And in 1775, when Pope’s Night is coming up, George Washington realizes that, hey, we shouldn’t have this massive demonstration of these traditional New England, discontent with Catholicism by burning the Pope in effigy when we’re trying so hard to get the Quebecois to come in on our side of this war. So on November 5th, 1775, he issues a general order saying, you dummies don’t do this. Or more specifically, he says that the commander in chief has been apprised of a design formed for the observance of the ridiculous and childish custom of burning the effigy of the Pope. He’s pretty clear on where he stands here. He cannot help but express his surprise that there should be officers and soldiers in this army so void of common sense as not to see the impropriety of such a step at this juncture. At a time when we are soliciting and have almost obtained the friendship and alliance of the people of Canada, whom we ought to consider as brethren embarked in the same cause. At such a juncture and in such circumstances, to be insulting their religion is so monstrous as not to be suffered or excused.
Jake:
So between the order to not celebrate Pope’s Night, the realization that we need to get the Quebecois on our side. And then the fact that, hey, this has been a big party in defense of the British crown. Oh, we’re not really doing that in Boston anymore in 1775. That really marks the end of Pope’s Night in any big way in Boston. I will say it doesn’t mark the end of our deep seated ancient anti-Catholic bias. That took a little longer. Remember the Ursuline Convent Riot, still going strong in 1834, I think it is. So it took us a little longer to get beyond the biases that led to Pope’s night, but Pope’s night sort of goes away post-Siege of Boston.
Jake:
How did I do? Did I get that under 10? I don’t think I could do that.
Meet the Historians: Puritan Beliefs
Jake:
All right. So at this point, I want to bring up our panelists. Lori and Jonathan, you’re going to come join us up. Thank you so much for joining us today. I’m going to have each of you introduce yourselves briefly, but just please welcome Lori Rogers Stokes and Jonathan Chu to the stage. Lori, maybe you want to introduce yourself first?
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
Okay. Hello. I am Lori Stokes. I’m a public historian and an independent scholar. I study the people we call the Puritans, a name they never used for themselves, Congreationalism amongst all the people who lived in this place over the first 200 years of the colonizing period.
Jonathan Chu:
Jonathan Chu. I’m an emeritus professor of history at UMass Boston. I also am the emeritus Bernard Balin, editor of the New England Quarterly. I started off in life studying 17th century New England Puritans and religious descent in Massachusetts. More recently, I’ve been studying what passes for money during the American Revolution.
Jake:
Well, that makes me want to have another season of history and be able to talk more about that. But alas, we are here to talk about those early days in the colony. So I wonder if we could rewind from, I feel like the image that I have in my head of Pope’s night is really that sort of mid-18th century at its height where you have the effigies being burned. Let’s go back to the early days of the colony and talk about where some of those attitudes would have originated. I very much have the mental image of the Puritans as… A sort of dour, stern, fun-hating group, but also as a, I think it’s a misconception, but I always think of early Massachusetts as being a pure theocracy, where church and state were one and there was no room for, religious dissent in the early days. But I feel like there was more wiggle room than that really, than my mental image allows for. Can you set me straight a little bit?
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
I’m always setting straight on this. If you want to look at a theocracy in the 17th century, it would have been England, where church officials were in the actual government, and the government set the rules for what people could believe. And that was one of the things that the Puritans really wanted to get away from when they came here. If you say they were conservative, it’s funny because they were very serious and focused, but I wouldn’t call them conservative because the minute they got here, like in record time, they set up a new way of worshiping, a new form of government. They were very much separated church and state in that, no minister could serve in the government, and if you were in the government and you were excommunicated by your church, you could not be removed from office. They did seek the advice of ministers. They didn’t always take it. So I think our theme tonight will be like, there’s no one monolithic truth about any group of people. They weren’t great. They weren’t terrible. And I think their struggles with Pope’s Night for 150 years really demonstrate that.
Jonathan Chu:
I think one of the problems, too, is this is a theology or a structure of belief, that’s created an opposition to a theocracy. And so one of the things that is central to Puritanism is its intense congregationalism. It’s intensely resistant to authority from above. But it’s a religion, so it has to be the same. There has to be an orthodoxy. So who gets to decide what the orthodoxy is? And if you have no authority, you have lots of people talking about things that they believe fervently in, and they think they’re talking about the same thing. Try that in any community and see how long you keep to what is the singular idea. Yeah.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
As we discussed Pope’s Night, who makes up the people will become more and more important from the 1630s through the 1680s. You didn’t come here if you weren’t a congregationalist Puritan. You just didn’t do it because everyone knew that’s what the deal was here. After that point, that was no longer as true. So you could have more success in saying, you guys can all work in your individual congregations to come up with how you’re going to worship, and have a result where it was pretty stable and pretty uniform, that might not always be the case.
Jonathan Chu:
One of the metaphors or things that have evolved that goes through a cycle of generations, there’s that generational tension that exists in Puritanism. And one of the best examples I used to like to lecture to my class on was the way in which Puritans sang.
Jonathan Chu:
So they started off in a system called line singing The minister would sing a line The congregation would respond with it Now, over the years, one gets someone who sings like me, My son at three already had decided I didn’t sing very well. Nonetheless, the minister conveys a degree of authority. So the congregation would follow suit. Well, by two generations, you have what many people start to call a cacophony of noise. And by the early 18th century, people are suggesting Maybe you ought to do what’s called regular singing You should have notes You might even introduce, God forbid, the organ And what this does is over something that is fundamental to the faith Getting the spiritual core of what it means Of what the Psalms mean, and now it’s become a point of division. But both sides think they’re right.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
And this will definitely come up, this sort of thinking, when we talk about, Pope’s Night, because one of the things that made other English people, in the Americas look askance at the Congregationalist Puritans was that they didn’t want to do anything by rote. We’re not going to have annual holidays. We’re not going to have anything where you think, oh yeah, I know what that’s going to be like and what we’re going to do. singing. Like, if you’re telling me that we need instruments in the church to cover up bad singing, then what’s the singing for? Is it to enjoy as something pretty, or is it for God? So their desire to have everything be spontaneous and natural, and not human beings deciding that a day is special and it’s a holy day, you know, is going to come into play over and over with the whole idea of an annual Pope’s Night celebration.
Religious Dissent in Early Massachusetts
Jake:
Well, I can see in the early days how we get some of the anti-Catholic bias that feeds into Pope’s eye. Some of it, a lot of it originates from merry old England, but also we’re here, on the ragged edge of the empire and the French, New France is just on the other side of the woods. The French and their Wabanaki allies are ever present in the New England imagination. There aren’t a lot of actual Catholics here in those times. And we have this, again, coming back to my sort of probably flawed mental image of the Puritans. It seems like they have created a very exclusive colony in the early days. We know that Anne Hutchinson gets banned for introducing dangerous new ideas during the antinomian controversy. Controversy, but how much of that sort of singularity of thought or of religious expression is real and how much of that am I inventing? I know that pretty early on there are people living here, maybe they’re not fully participating in all the aspects of government and church and society, but there must be folks who aren’t adherents to the congregational church pretty soon after arriving.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
Yes. I can’t remember which town a congregation was in by the 1640s. The ministers had become Baptists. There were always a few people who were finding new light for a different way, which they would have seen as an advancement of congregationalism into something better. Yeah, that was true. I mean, if you say the group were 99% homogenous, that means 1% was not. I think the only thing that united 100% of those people was hating Catholics. Oh, anybody would have been in on that. If you ask people like, who did the Puritans probably hate and fear the most here? Most people would say indigenous people. It was Catholics. Oh, they just could not. I can’t repeat the language they used to describe Catholics, and they hated that they were right north of us.
Jake:
Some of it is carved into a pew on the second floor of this building.
Jonathan Chu:
One of the groups I studied in the 1650s were, among groups, they were called Ranters, Quakers, and Other Notorious Heretics. So what emerges in Salem, on the fringes in Kittery, Maine, even in downtown Boston in about the 1650s, is a significant group of people that we know of today as members of the Society of Friends. Quakers in the 17th century weren’t exactly the Quakers we envision today. They were rowdy. Frequently, they would do these public demonstrations. The most notorious Quakers in one year decided to demonstrate the spiritual nakedness of the Puritan church. So two women in December took off their clothes and marched down the main street, of, I think it was Salem, to demonstrate this problem. So there are these group of people who are clearly opposite Puritanism.
Jonathan Chu:
But 10% of the population of these people lived on the fringes of Salem near the Peabody Line, across the river, which, if you had to get to the meeting house in the middle of winter, was kind of treacherous. So they meet in accordance with Quaker doctrine, which, by the way, is also quite similar to Puritanism. The centrality of the Quaker faith is to speak from the Christ inward dwelling. That is, to examine your soul, to examine your thinking, and to try to respond as God directs you to respond.
Jonathan Chu:
These 10% of the Quakers in Salem are never bothered. They’re initially, periodically, a group of outside Quakers come through And everybody goes into a frenzy because they’re disorderly They’re taking their clothes off, in the middle of winter They’re obviously crazy, or at least that’s how I characterize them, But the others are, integrated into the community, One of them is actually married to the town’s largest landowner Yeah. And when you’re faced with these people whose only crime is they don’t want to pay to support a minister that they don’t use, a town service that they don’t use. By the way, this is starting to appear elsewhere in the 1660s as towns spread out and start to spread into new congregations and new parishes. So, it’s a kind of tension that gets built into the system, particularly as time passes, which makes it harder and harder to enforce this notion of orthodoxy.
Andros, Christmas, and Colonial Power
Jake:
And then suddenly in 1689, our good old friend Sir Edmund Andros arrives as the newly appointed royal governor, sort of direct control by the crown of our government here in Massachusetts. And the first thing he does is force a Christmas celebration at Old South. It wasn’t that old yet, I guess, at the South Meeting House. And people, particularly Samuel Sewell, who was deeply entrenched against the idea of Christmas celebrations in New England, lose their minds over this. And we have this period of the dominion of New England, the dominion rule under Sermon Andrews. And we think of this time as being a moment in Massachusetts history where we’re suddenly forced to tolerate this large body of Anglicans in our midst that’s never been here before. We’re suddenly forced to tolerate Quakers and all these Baptists are becoming a big thing by then. And we remember it as sort of a time of fracture. But one of our conversations leading up to today, you pointed out that even though we remember it that way, the colony is still overwhelmingly congregational at that time. Why do we think of it as this time of a religious fracture?
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
This is that interesting merger. This is how politics and religion mixed here by that point. Within a year of the Winthrop fleet landing here in 1630, they had put in writing that they were going to create a separate. Political entity from England.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
And they had Castle Island fortified against an English governor who might come, right, by 1634. They hid this from England. Their charter said they could do anything they want, make any laws they wanted, as long as they were not repugnant to the laws of England. And England at this time was busy with their Dutch wars. And so Massachusetts got away with becoming a very independent state with a different state religion than England. And so by the time Andros came in 1689, after King Philip’s War in 1675, Charles II, newly restored, well, restored at that point, had stripped the colony of that charter and said, you people clearly cannot govern yourselves. You almost destroyed yourselves in a civil war. So we are taking over the government. So being someone in Massachusetts meant you were a congregationalist and you were a Massachusetts resident, political and religious independence. So first the charter is stripped away, and now we have to have a royally appointed governor. And then Charles II dies, his brother comes to the throne, and now you’ve got Andros. It’s another heavier load of you’re not an independent state, you definitely belong to us and we’re going to throw into question every land deed everyone’s title to their land in the whole of New England just to prove it.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
When he walked through the streets with his armed guard to celebrate Christmas at the South Meeting House, not at the North Meeting House, the South Congregational one, people saw it as a political, open political war. Like, you are here to force us to give up everything that makes us who we are. At that point, you know, by four or five generations in. And I leap ahead, like, during the revolution, I think on April 19th, 1775, when the revolution began, some British official let loose and just said, the whole reason for this war is your horrible religion. So the two are wrapped together, like being here meant you had a certain religion and a certain political entity that were both based on independent, ground-up voting. And that’s why it was a time of that turmoil, because if you’re going to introduce tolerance and you have to have Anglicans and they have to have their own meeting house, that’s not just a religious move, that’s a political move.
Jonathan Chu:
One of the ironies of all of this is that William III, when he comes in, he passes the edict of toleration. And by the way, Quakers in Old England are pushing for this because they’re concerned about Quakers in New England. It creates this irony in Old England as well as New England, but it’s identified as politics. It’s not identified as a religious thing. Even in that, it’s a relatively narrow notion of tolerance. So, it’s a narrowness, but it’s also something that is seen as terribly oppressive.
Jake:
Well, it’s interesting. Lori, a few minutes ago, you pointed out that the Puritans didn’t love fixed holidays, including Christmas and Samuel Sewell’s many writings about keeping Christmas out of Massachusetts. So in a way, it’s not surprising that in the early days of the colony, even though Guy Fawkes Day was being celebrated in Mary Old by that time, that it didn’t really take off here immediately. It started to be recognized during the Andros years, during the Dominion. What made that change?
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
By that point in 1689, New Englanders, the English people here, had almost 60 years of obfuscating with England. Like, oh gosh, we’re nothing but loyal. We’re not doing anything you wouldn’t do, knowing that no one was going to come check. And now someone is there to check and saying, oh, it seems like you are not celebrating the restoration of your monarch. Is that true? Are you not celebrating Guy Fawkes, you know, the foiling of his plan? Are you not loyal to the crown? And then New England had to do it, had to do a few times like, oh, we certainly are. We’ve been celebrating it in our own way. We’ve celebrated in our hearts this whole time. It’s our hearts and minds. But we’ve also talked, like, 1689 is early, but there’s a long, long tradition of just mob violence that comes in the 18th century, where people here were into some mob violence. So I think you get the most protests, you get some congregational ministers saying, you know, Pope’s Day, thank God it wasn’t such a big deal in our town this year. You get that initial pushback, but then just, again, the political need to do it. no, we need to celebrate the king took over, and people realized it was inevitable.
Pope’s Night as Protest and Political Theater
Jonathan Chu:
The kind of activity that the Guy Fawkes Day represents has a long tradition, in Western Europe throughout, it starts in the Middle Ages, and it’s a kind of way of letting off steam culturally. Various groups in France and in England would have these moments in which you simply let people run riot. Sometimes it’s in response to a bad harvest. Some historians have characterized it as an informal, formal process of political protest by people who don’t have the vote. Guy Fawkes is a way of focusing it in a way that in England, clearly the anti-Catholicism thing works just fine for Anglicans. It diverts attention from ills, and they’re carried on throughout the 18th century. But they also become kind of controlled and sponsored by people. People start to realize that these are very useful things to help advance a particular position. And it’s relatively inexpensive to do this. Haul up a bunch of alcohol and good food and people will show up.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
That’s such a good point to bring up because it was another way in which New England tried to distance itself from everything they had ever known back in the old world. Here, everyone had to vote. There was no underclass who lived in hovels and couldn’t vote and built up a lot of steam against, you know, the authorities because town governments were elected. The Commonwealth government was elected and they would have been proud to say, like, we don’t need an opportunity for people to let off steam. We don’t have steam building up like you do in other places.
Jonathan Chu:
Philadelphia, right after the passage of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, really starts to suppress these mass movements. And one of the reasons they do it is one of the little-known geography facts, is that Independence Hall sits right on the edge of what used to be the free black community. And the free black community understood what the Declaration of Independence said. They weren’t interested in the list of charges against the king. They liked that first part about that all men are created equal. And what they start to do is they start to have their own parades and their own demonstrations. And they take on the characteristics of the political parades that were put on in support of the Federalists to ratify the Constitution. And leaders of Philadelphia think that this is not such a good idea. So they start to regulate those parades.
Church Divisions and Congregational Disputes
Jake:
He sort of pointed out that new england society massachusetts society will say was a little more egalitarian and maybe needed fewer opportunity fewer of those pressure release valves to blow off steam and yet, you go around not so much in in boston but if you go around any of the surrounding towns you’ll probably see two white meeting houses sort of glowering at each other across a green where there’s a, even though there’s a lot more unity and more egalitarianism, it seems like there are pressures that build up within the church that eventually, start driving some separation. Jonathan, you talked a little bit about music as one of the catalysts for driving some of the wedges early on in the congregational church. Why do we end up with these two churches facing each other across the town green so many places?
Jonathan Chu:
Because they’re basic disagreements over what constitutes orthodoxy. Should you baptize children? Some say yes, some say no. They’re not quite sure what that is. Is the Eucharist literally the body and blood of Christ, or is it just something in remembrance? Who’s going to appoint the minister? One of the things that Massachusetts requires, through the 18th century is that you have to pay taxes to support a recognized minister of the gospel. Well, everybody knows that doesn’t count. Catholics don’t count. But as you get into the 18th century.
Jonathan Chu:
How do you decide who that is? Well, Some groups, particularly in Scotland, organize something called a presbyter. So it’s a kind of hierarchy. It’s a group of ministers who then pass judgment on aspiring ministers. You can’t do that in Massachusetts. On the other hand, you can in Pennsylvania. But a Presbyterian in Pennsylvania in the 18th century is remarkably similar, to a congregational minister in New England. In New England, what comes to be created is something called a consociation, a group of ministers. But groups of ministers can also disagree, and they do. What do you do about emotional comprehension of saving grace? You’ve explored that in great detail, and you find that, oh, wait a minute, there are lots of different ways of doing this. So, as you disagree, you split over the church. I haven’t got to the point of who’s going to pay for the minister.
Jake:
That’s my next question.
Who Paid the Ministers?
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
That’s such an interesting story, because as Jonathan alludes to, I study church records, congregational church records, and it is dynamic reading when they are taking down the minutes of a church meeting. Yes, the salary of the minister, and that’s the term they used, was paid by the town. So the town would be involved, like when the church, the church always chose the minister, and then informed the town, we’ve chosen this candidate. You’d have candidates auditioning for as long as it took for the church body to say, this is the person we’d like to invite. Then you tell the town. And you, at the church, will tell the town, we are offering 30 pounds per year, because this is going to go into the taxation.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
And then it’s just a free-for-all, depending on the town, the time, and what the situation is, of the town saying 30 pounds. That seems like a lot. Maybe it could be 10 pounds and wood delivered every three months. Or the opposite way, like, you know what? Times are good. This is a good guy. Let’s go for 40. We don’t want to lose him. And then the records, in church records and in the civil records, of ministers trying to get their actual pay. Because it could be held up by anything. Like, okay, we’re hiring you now in September and we’re going to backdate your pay. You’ll get your first payment in next March. And then we’ll do it like every three and a half months for a few years. And then if things got hard, if there were economic hard times, it just stopped. Ministers will go for years without any pay whatsoever. And the town, would kick it back to the church, like, well, you take up a special collection. We can’t tax people anymore because we’re all broke. The church would kick it back to town, like, you promised that you would raise taxation to this level. Nobody wanted to pay the minister.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
You’d go through these extremely hard times where people were just not being paid to perform this function that was so, so vitally important to the church, the congregation, the town, the region, the way. And it does speak well for the ministers that many of them would continue to perform all of their duties for years without pay. Some of them doing their own kind of market gardening on the side, like they’d work the couple acres they got with the parish house, as it were, just to make ends meet. So it’s one of those things, again, where it’s not a monolith. Like, yeah, everyone supports the minister through taxation, unless we just don’t feel like we can do it.
Jonathan Chu:
I always wondered what people thought of the minister who hadn’t gotten a pay raise in 20 years and asked for one?
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
Oh, there’s records in the town of Rowley where, well, actually, there’s actually a better one. This poor man who was a minister in, oh, gosh, I’m going to forget. It’s a town near Grafton, Westboro? I’m not sure. He said there was like a kind of battle going on in the town about what his pay was going to be because he had asked for a raise. And he’s sitting at home at night, and there’s like banging on the door and three men show up from town meeting like the mob. Like, oh, we hear you’re interested in more money. We’re here to tell you maybe you should stop asking for more money because that’s not going to happen. And he’s writing this in the church record and you could see that it scared him and he was insulted and scared and all these things. They could play some very hard ball with the minister because… Even though what he did was so valued and he would be respected. You can’t help in a society like this, in that early stage, proto-capitalist society, anyone who didn’t make money and own land, like the minister didn’t own the land. He lived on the land that was set aside for the minister. If you weren’t a landowner and a moneymaker, you’re kind of the odd guy out. And so while they will respect you, they probably respect you so much because they figure you’ll work without being paid at all, which many of them did.
Jake:
Well, you alluded to almost the opposite problem cropping up in some towns also, where rather than having no money to support a minister, you would have two respected ministers, two meeting houses, two congregations. Some of those fissures over the orthodoxy have started to bubble up. But Massachusetts law still says you must support the established minister of the town. So how do you decide at that point, which of these fairly equally respected churches gets the town tax money?
Jonathan Chu:
You pay them both.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
I mean, this is what the town would say to the church. And the church members knew, like, we’re having a divide within this church. We could split. But the town cannot support two ministers. Usually this wasn’t a problem throughout the 17th, well, into like 1750, because people were always eager to move to a new town, form a new town, have new land grants, totally free land. Like, we’re happy to leave here and start anew. So when you start to run out of places to do that, and you had to realize like maybe the town is going to have to support two different ministers, it was rough. It was a tough moment.
Jonathan Chu:
It’s also the way in which the decentralization of New England towns start to take place. So you have the children of the old families moving out and living on the edges. So in some ways that mitigates the tension and the division, But it also provides a vehicle for separation along doctrinal lines if necessary. But it can just be the ordinary processes of population growth.
Jake:
You’d follow the minister that you most associated with?
Jonathan Chu:
No, actually, it’s the reverse. The way in which the New England town was originally designed was you were given strips of land near the town center, and then you had more distant pastures that you would work. Well, when you have children, the children get the pastures, so they move out, and they start to develop their own population centers. And as they do that, then they come back and they say, look, walking the mile back into town for church is too far. I’ve got three kids. We have a community out here. We want a minister out here. And that could be just a kind of separation as a separate ward of the town, or it could just be, we want a new town.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
And if a town gets big, like Boston, you can’t put a thousand people in one building. You’re going to have to have a second church. So people had to really organize a congregation that could pay the minister through special offerings, special collections, because you weren’t guaranteed. Like, first church Boston is guaranteed the tax support. Second church Boston is not. Third church Boston is not, and less and less.
Jake:
Eventually that tax support of churches is going to go away and in took a long time it’s well after the american revolution it’s 1830 right 1331.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
I think 1831 was the final disassociation.
Massachusetts Disestablishes Its Churches
Jake:
And in my sort of ill-informed back of my mind i always assumed well we have a first amendment now, no establishment of religion but then you look at the chronology and you realize 1830-something doesn’t exactly align with the adoption of the Bill of Rights. So what’s actually driving that disestablishment, I guess you call it? What’s driving Massachusetts to say, okay, we’re no longer going to use tax money to support any of the local churches?
Jonathan Chu:
There are a couple of things that are at work in Massachusetts. First, the system is probably broken down, I think, by the mid to late 18th century. Because if you could prove that you supported a recognized minister of the gospel, you didn’t have to pay taxes in support of the established church. The Constitution… Applies an end to this process. For me, the Constitution has always been an example of the way in which what a friend of mine always calls in the United States is we do it. In fact, in the United States, we have an established church. It’s called banquet. It’s when you go to a banquet before they let you eat, somebody says something about a higher being, and then you can eat. In the 1830s, the limits of banquet religion are really quite narrow to what we would call mainline Protestant groups now. And the reason that that exists is because you have an established church in Massachusetts that’s tax-supported. You have established churches in the South that are tax-supported, but are they Church of England? Oh, no, no, no, wait a minute. You can’t be Church of England, so you can’t even be Anglican. They have to be this thing called Episcopal.
Jonathan Chu:
And even in those areas, there are also large groups of Baptists. And the Baptists are different kinds of Baptists. In Pennsylvania, forget Pennsylvania, it’s got Quakers, it’s got Amish, it’s got Dutch Reformed. They can’t agree And in point of fact That’s why William Penn Who’s trying to sell land, Doesn’t have a religious requirement So all of these Different states now Have to have the same government And they wisely When it comes time to debate religion They say, okay We’re just not going to touch it, And if you read the Bill of Rights correctly, it does not bar a state from having an established church. It says Congress shall make no law abridging the right of freedom of conscience.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
That’s so important. Yeah, I think you’ve hit the heart of it there, like Massachusetts and other New England states now. Still had that identity. It was still going strong. Like, we are congregationalists here. Yes, there are other, there are Baptists and other things now, but our whole identity has been congregational. It was almost symbolic. Like, we must continue to support congregational church. And congregationalists remain the majority. I mean, I’d say up to the 1840s when lots of Irish people started coming in. If you went to any town, most of the people there were still a congregationalist. So that died hard as an identity that you might support even in token, like just to have some line in the state constitution that said, this is the way, but it wasn’t.
Puritan Laws and Blasphemy
Jake:
Well, it took us a solid 200 years from the founding of Boston and Massachusetts as a congregational Puritan colony to officially disestablish our church. And we’ve had almost darn close to 200 more years since then. But there are still some legal holdovers from that older era. And as we were prepping for this episode, I think the one that struck my funny bone the most was that it is still technically illegal in Massachusetts to bring Christ’s name to ill repute.
Jonathan Chu:
To contumeliously reproach God and his creation in judgment.
Jake:
What he said. So what does that mean for us? I feel like I’ve been guilty of this many times recently. I probably need to be on the run from the law. What does this actually mean for us today? When was the last time that somebody was prosecuted under that law?
Jonathan Chu:
1926.
Jake:
Oof, that’s not that long ago.
Jonathan Chu:
He was acquitted, by the way, but convicted of sedition. I think one of the things that we mistaken, and I take full responsibility for this statement, blasphemy in the past functions as sedition or treason or… A secular crime of disorder. One who blasphemes is unreliable. One who challenges the cultural norms is seditious or treasonous. And that line, that measure, is what my law school professors would call a rubber ruler.
Lori Rogers-Stokes:
When you look at the records, as you have, blasphemy was usually done when someone was drunk, which was another problem, that you were not supposed to be drunk, or having a violent argument, which was also not something that was okay. So blasphemy is usually part and parcel of other behaviors that meant someone was really trying to say, look, I’m not on board with the culture anymore. I’m making that clear.
Jonathan Chu:
And as evidence, reproaching God or denying his creation or judgment is, from a point of view of hard evidence, you either heard it or you didn’t.
Jake:
We’ll be conscious of the time. We’re hard up against our hour already.
What Comes After Hub History?
Jake:
So I’m going to move into the wrap up that you’ve all heard a hundred times before to learn more about Lori and Jonathan, figure out where to follow them and find out more about their work. You can go to this week’s show notes at hubhistory.com slash three six six. I’ll have some links about them. I’ll have the transcript of tonight’s conversation.
Jake:
If you want to hear more of my work after this podcast wraps, there are still four episodes of Queer Boston’s Pursuit of Happiness that are going to be released. Make sure to subscribe to those. That’s the show that I’m producing for Queer History Boston with Joan, who’s sitting right over there. Okay. Also, I know I’ve been saying this is the last show, but I am actually going to release one more after this. This will take me a week or two to put this show together for release, but I have been very neglectful of listener feedback over several months now. So I want to have one last show to sort of wrap up all the emails and things that people have sent I haven’t had a chance to acknowledge. So this is your last call. If you want to hear your words on the show, go ahead and get those emails, social media comments, things like that. And now it’s time for that. Also, don’t delete the feed from your podcast app of choice. You never know. I will probably release old episodes from time to time. I may decide to do a new episode once in a while in the future, not ruling it out. Then I’ll slowly be archiving some of the old shows to make sure that they outlive the feed whenever I stop paying for maintenance on the podcast feed. So stay tuned for all that. Now I will read our traditional outro. If you want to get in touch with me, you can email podcast at hubhistory.com. These days, as far as social media goes, Blue Sky and Mastodon are about it for me. So I’m Blue Sky. I’m hubhistory.com. Mastodon, it’s at hubhistoryatbetter.boston. I never remember the atbetter.boston part. And then also you can just go to the website, hubhistory.com, click on the contact us link. There’s a form there that will easily submit your feedback to me.
Jake:
I would say hit the subscribe link. But at this point, there’s really no point, I don’t suppose. But do get in touch. I want to do one more episode where I share all your feedback. For those of you who are listening at home later, that’s all for now. Stay safe out there, listeners. And for everybody who’s in the room with us tonight, again, thanks for being here. Let’s go next door to the parish house. We have some snacks. We have some soft drinks and stuff. And I have some books from the Hub History Library to get rid of. So let’s go have a wrap party next door. Thank you both for being here, this has been a ton of fun.






